88 points by tosh 3 days ago | 12 comments
simonw 6 hours ago
Pyodide is one of the hidden gems of the Python ecosystem. It's SO good at what it does, and it's nearly 8 years old now so it's pretty mature.

I love using Pyodide to build web UIs for trying out new Python libraries. Here's one I built a few weeks ago to exercise my pure-Python SQLite AST parser, for example: https://tools.simonwillison.net/sqlite-ast

It's also pretty easy[1] to get C or Rust libraries that have Python bindings compiled to a WebAssembly wheel that Pyodide can then load.

Here's a bit of a nutty example - the new Monty Python-like sandbox library (written in Rust) compiled to WASM and then loaded in Pyodide in the browser: https://simonw.github.io/research/monty-wasm-pyodide/pyodide...

[1] OK, Claude Code knows how to do it.

VagabundoP 2 hours ago
The who python web feels underused to be honest.

Maybe if browsers start shipping or downloading WASMs for python and others on request. And storing them for all sites going forward. Similar to how uv does it for for venvs it creates, there are standalone python version blobs.

iamcreasy 5 hours ago
How do you call those C/Rust libraries compiled from to webassembly from Python/Pyodide?
simonw 5 hours ago
You have to turn them into WebAssembly wheels, then you can import them as if they were regular Python modules.
fzumstein 3 hours ago
Pyodide powers xlwings Lite, a free Excel add-in that you can install from Excel’s add-in store with a single click. It outperforms Microsoft’s official Python in Excel solution in every coceivable way: price, privacy, speed, can install packages, can access the internet, can access local files, doesn’t have a usage quota, can automate Excel and create native UDFs. See https://lite.xlwings.org
devsda 6 hours ago
There's also xeus-cpp which is cpp based on wasm. Xeus-cpp and pyodide are the backends for Jupyterlite [1] kernels in browser.

It's actually a very good way to teach coding in python/c++(11, 17 or even 23), explore language features or your own library within browser and allow students to execute code by hosting just some static html pages and some assets without any backend.

1. https://jupyter.org/try-jupyter/lab/

QuadmasterXLII 6 hours ago
It works surprisingly well in terms of writing python for native execution, and then trying to share on the web and having it Just Work TM. Unfortunately, when I want python it's because I want numpy, scipy and friends, and once you bring them on board pyodide load times are long. As an example comparison: a face turning octahedron puzzle in python + pyodide, loads in 10 seconds https://cubes.hgreer.com/fto.html . Meanwhile, a megaminx puzzle in javascript (statically generated by python) loads in 200 ms https://cubes.hgreer.com/ssg/output.html
ianberdin 5 hours ago
Yea, I even built online ide based on Pyodide. Insane peace of software. You can try here: playcode.io/python
jasiek 4 hours ago
I've used it to put together a browser app to program walkie-talkies: https://codeplug.org
williamstein 3 hours ago
I tried to make a version of this using Zig once, but ran out of steam: https://cowasm.org/
shevy-java 3 hours ago
Everyone runs out of steam when it comes to WebAssembly. I used to wonder in the past why we hear so little about it, until I realised that nobody is really using it. Granted, there are those who use WebAssembly, but if we compare it to HTML, CSS, JavaScript, then WebAssembly is simply not existing anywhere near that level. After soon-to-be 10 years, that is very disappointing.
IshKebab 2 hours ago
Plenty of people are using Webassembly. Many more will use it once GC is properly supported and you don't need a JavaScript shim layer.
yjftsjthsd-h 4 hours ago
That is very cool. Has anyone made a nice beginner's learning environment out of it? Seems like it would solve some of the extra friction that makes it hard to get started.
cfu28 4 hours ago
I played around with it to build a little "intro to python" walkthrough on my blog a while back. It worked surprisingly well! I had a little trouble giving users the ability to ctrl-c if they accidentally wrote an infinite loop though lol (piodide supports it I just didn't implement it): https://cfu288.com/blog/2024-05_cwc-intro-to-python/
wisty 4 hours ago
Jupyterlite - a lot of jupyter trial versions use it.
yawnxyz 7 hours ago
no but it works great in conjunction with observable and d3js for pretty interactives!
walterlw 2 hours ago
could you please point to an example? For my project i'm currently animating matplotlib plots and walk through the video later, but rendering times are quite painful.
jacob019 7 hours ago
Anyone using it with nodejs to make a sandbox for code agents?
simonw 5 hours ago
I've done some experiments along those lines with Pyodide in Deno: https://til.simonwillison.net/deno/pyodide-sandbox
b89kim 6 hours ago
ChatGPT's Canvas uses Pyodide for sandboxing, but it's not designed for coding agents. Node.js environment is usually better for agents. Pyodide restricts server-side functionality, and fetching external URLs often needs proxying due to sandbox. By the way, pyodide is still good option for interactive visualizer or deploying small webapps require data processing.
jcheng 7 hours ago
For that purpose I think most people are using bubblewrap or seatbelt/sandbox-exec with CPython.
westurner 3 hours ago
From https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47171887 re: [agent] sandboxing :

pydantic/monty, vercel-labs/just-bash, amla sandbox, csl-core, microsandbox, workerd, wasmtime-mte

containers/bubblewrap: https://github.com/containers/bubblewrap#sandboxing

The bubblewrap readme mentions containers as binaries with binctr; I guess without overlayfs or other file-level re-deduplication due to the container fs in the binary.

Perhaps similarly, also TIL UKI are easier for UEFI Secure Boot to check signatures on than (kernel, initrd) pairs

shevy-java 3 hours ago
WebAssembly will reach a breakthrough in the same year as GNU Hurd will dominate, together with the Desktop-Linux-of-the-year.
anarhackist 7 hours ago
[dead]